At the Bench
Grown, not found · Field guide
WorkshopWhat each material actually does under the lap. Hardness is only part of the story — cleavage, heat tolerance, orientation and refractive index all decide whether a piece of rough becomes a stone or a lesson.
The four things that decide how a material behaves
- Hardness sets your lap sequence and how long it takes. It does not tell you how tough the material is. Diamond is the hardest thing there is and cleaves perfectly in four directions.
- Cleavage is where the material would rather split than be cut. Distinct or perfect cleavage means light pressure, careful transfers, and no shortcuts.
- Heat tolerance decides your dopping method. Anything strained (Verneuil boules), anything glassy (nanosital), anything that conducts heat poorly (CZ), and anything with fluid inclusions gets warmed and cooled slowly, or dopped cold.
- Refractive index decides the design. Higher RI, shallower pavilion.
Material by material
| Material | Mohs | Cleavage | Heat | Orientation | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Diamond | 10 | Perfect, four directions | Fine | Cubic — none | Specialist equipment. The cleavage is the whole risk |
| Moissanite | 9.25 | None | Fine | Table ⟂ c-axis, essential | Cuts slowly, eats cheap laps. Doubling if mis-oriented |
| Corundum | 9 | None; parting on twins | Fine | Table ⟂ c-axis for color | Verneuil boules are strained — no thermal shock |
| Chrysoberyl | 8.5 | Distinct, one direction | Fine | Orient for the color change | Get the orientation wrong and the change disappears |
| LuAG | 8.5 | None | Fine | Cubic — none | Very dense. Deeper designs glow more |
| YAP | 8.5 | None reported | Fine | Biaxial — check with a polariscope | Thin published data. Measure your own |
| YAG | 8–8.5 | None | Fine | Cubic — none | Critical angle ≈33°; use a high-RI design |
| GAGG | ≈8 | None | Fine | Cubic — none | Data still thin. Treat specs as approximate |
| Spinel | 8 | None | Verneuil is strained | Cubic — none | The friendliest material on this list for a beginner |
| Cubic zirconia | 8–8.5 | None | Sensitive — dop cold | Cubic — none | Critical angle ≈27°. Crazes on thermal shock |
| Beryl | 7.5–8 | Imperfect basal | Sensitive | Table ⟂ c-axis | Brittle girdles. Find the seed plate before preforming |
| Quartz | 7 | None | Sensitive to shock | Table ⟂ c-axis for amethyst | Orange peel and scratching if the prepolish is rushed |
| Nanosital | 7 | None | Sensitive — warm slowly | None — isotropic aggregate | No zoning, no inclusions, no orientation. Very forgiving |
| GGG | 6.5–7 | None | Fine | Cubic — none | Soft for its class. Overpolishes; scratches in wear |
| Rutile | 6–6.5 | Distinct, prismatic | Fine | Table ⟂ c-axis | Soft and cleaves. Light pressure or you'll chip meets |
| Strontium titanate | 5–6 | None | Fine | Cubic — none | Very soft, brittle. Critical angle ≈24° |
| Lithium niobate | 5–5.5 | None | Fine | Table ⟂ c-axis | Soft. Doubling is visible; design for RI 2.25 |
| KTP | 5 | Distinct | Fine | Biaxial | Soft and cleaves. Display material |
| YVO₄ | ≈5 | Distinct | Fine | Table ⟂ c-axis, or embrace the doubling | Enormous birefringence. Difficult, rewarding |
| Zincite | 4–5 | Perfect, one direction | Fine | Table ⟂ c-axis | Cleaves readily. Not a jewelry stone |
| Fluorite | 4 | Perfect, four directions | Sensitive | Cubic — none | The hardest thing here to finish without losing |
Critical angles, for design selection
Pick a design specified for the material's refractive index. If you must adapt one, this is the number that governs whether the pavilion returns light or leaks it.
| Material | Refractive index | Critical angle |
|---|---|---|
| Fluorite | 1.434 | 44.2° |
| Quartz | 1.544–1.553 | 40.2° |
| Beryl | 1.564–1.600 | 39.4° |
| Nanosital | 1.65–1.70 | 37.3° |
| Spinel (flux) | ≈1.718 | 35.6° |
| Chrysoberyl | 1.745–1.755 | 34.8° |
| Corundum | 1.762–1.770 | 34.5° |
| YAG | 1.833 ±0.010 | 33.1° |
| LuAG | 1.84 | 32.9° |
| GAGG | ≈1.92 | 31.4° |
| YAP (Pr:YAlO₃) | ≈1.92–1.95 | 31.2° |
| GGG | 1.970 (+0.060) | 30.5° |
| Zincite | 2.013–2.029 | 29.7° |
| YVO₄ | 1.99 / 2.22 | 28.4° |
| Cubic zirconia | 2.15–2.18 | 27.5° |
| Lithium niobate | 2.21–2.30 | 26.4° |
| Strontium titanate | 2.409 | 24.5° |
| Diamond | 2.417 | 24.4° |
| Moissanite (SiC) | 2.648–2.691 | 22.0° |
| Rutile | 2.616–2.903 | 21.2° |
General notes that apply to most grown material
- Verneuil rough is strained. Boules split lengthwise on cooling for a reason. Preform gently, don't shock it thermally, and expect the occasional piece to come apart.
- Check for a seed plate in anything hydrothermal before you preform. Plan the stone so it falls outside the finished shape, or somewhere it won't show face-up.
- Cubic materials have no orientation. Spinel, CZ, YAG, LuAG, GGG, GAGG, fluorite, diamond. Preform however the rough suits you. This is a real time saving.
- Uniaxial materials generally want the table perpendicular to the c-axis — that puts the optic axis vertical, which minimizes visible doubling and usually gives the best face-up color. Corundum, beryl, quartz, moissanite, rutile.
- Color-change material is oriented for the change, not for brightness. Preform, then look at it under both light sources along different axes before you commit to a table.
- Overpolishing is a soft-material problem. Below about hardness 7, dwelling on the polish lap rounds facet edges and blurs meets. Light pressure, short passes, check often.
- Grown material is usually inclusion-free, which means yield is high and you can plan the stone to fill the rough. That's a genuine advantage over natural material and it's part of what makes synthetics good for learning.
Polish, roughly
Every cutter has their own combination and laps vary enormously, so treat this as a starting point rather than doctrine.
| Material group | Prepolish | Polish lap | Polish agent |
|---|---|---|---|
| Corundum, chrysoberyl, moissanite | 3000–8000 grit diamond | Ceramic, tin, or tin-lead | 50k–100k diamond |
| YAG, LuAG, GAGG, spinel, CZ | 3000–8000 grit diamond | Ceramic, tin, tin-lead | 50k–100k diamond, or alumina on tin |
| Quartz, beryl, nanosital | 3000–8000 grit diamond | Tin, lucite, phenolic, or tin-lead | Cerium oxide, or 60k–100k diamond, light pressure |
| GGG, rutile, lithium niobate, YVO₄, strontium titanate | 3000–14000 grit diamond, light pressure | Tin or a soft ceramic | 100k diamond or alumina — short passes, check constantly |
| Zincite, fluorite, KTP | Very fine diamond, minimal pressure | Tin, wax, or a soft lap | Alumina or cerium oxide. Expect to lose some |
Grown, not found: the field guide
Start here
Nature barely does
Nature never does
Reference
A reference to lab-grown gem materials, written for cutters. Values are typical published figures; ranges vary with composition, dopant and measurement wavelength. Nothing here is a substitute for a laboratory report on a stone whose identity matters commercially.